Homemade - Small Batch - Hand Crafted

Welcome to Dairy Island. Next year in 2025 we will celebrate our 50th anniversary serving the Chagrin Valley. Since 1976 the Cibik family has been creating spectacular summer ice cream treats. We’ve got your ice cream.

Join us this summer for the greatest ice cream desserts, customer service, and classic rock found anywhere on the planet. We truly appreciate your business. Thank you.

Cibik’s Craft Ice Creams

 Our small batch homemade ice creams are hand crafted and produced right in our store in Bainbridge. The super premium ice creams that we create are made with 15% butter fat milk and cream, 100% pure bourbon vanilla extract, and only the finest ingredients.

Flavors: Butter Pecan,  Mint Chocolate Chip, Cookies & Cream, Dark Chocolate Raspberry, Rocky Road, Lemon Bar, Strawberry, Superman, I Love Lucy (Red Raspberry and Dark Chocolate), Vegan flavors made with Coconut Milk: Dark Chocolate,  Hawaiian Noises (Pineapple, Shredded Coconut and Dark Chocolate)

Frozen Custards 

Our frozen custard is recognized as one of the best soft serves available. 10% butter fat cream and egg yolks create a smooth and creamy frozen custard experience. With our base flavors of Vanilla, Chocolate and Twist, we enjoy creating endless frozen custard concoctions. Enjoy our frozen custard in our hand mixed Milkshakes, Classic Sundaes, Parfaits, Banana Splits and Hurricanes. Root Beer Floats and old fashioned Chocolate Sodas too.

 

CREATE your own ICE CREAM

Our contest that encourages guests to create their own unique flavors. The best flavor of the year wins FREE ice cream for the whole next summer and their flavor is featured on our menu for the whole world to enjoy.

 

CREATE your own ICE CREAM Contest Winners:

 Ambrosia by Taylor Baryak – 2023

 The Ultimate Banana Bread by Veronica Corsillo – 2022

 Queen Bee by Sarah Freeman – 2021

 Peanut Butter Blast by Christine Sutter – 2020

 Chocolate Rice Krispie Treat by Sydney Corcoran – 2019

 Chagrin S’Mores by Ella Laneve – 2018

 Take Me Out to the Ballgame by Mia Conti – 2017

Pineapple Dole Whip

This soft serve is refreshing, tasteful, and delicious. A very popular non-dairy alternative. Try our Pina Colada Sundae made with Pineapple Dole Whip, Shredded Coconut and Honey.