Our homemade ice creams are hand crafted and produced on premise at Dairy Island in Bainbridge Ohio. The super premium ice creams that we create are made with 15% butter fat milk & cream sourced from Mid West farms, 100% pure bourbon vanilla extract, and only the finest ingredients. Favorites include: Butter Pecan, I Love Lucy, Cookies & Cream, Superman, Vegan Dark Chocolate, Lemon Bar, Rocky Road, and Elaine’s Sensational Turtle Delight. 

Our frozen custard is considered by many as one of the best soft serves available. We start with 10% butter fat milk and cream and add egg yolks to create a rich, smooth and creamy frozen custard experience. With our base flavors of vanilla, chocolate, and twist, we enjoy creating endless frozen custard concoctions. Our made to order Custard Cups include: Shock The Monkey, Lemon, Hawaiian Noises, Cherry Pie, Cereal Killer, and Franks & Beans.

We encourage guests to create their own flavors too. The best flavor of the year wins free ice cream for the entire next season. Previous winners include: The Ultimate Banana Bread by Veronica Corsillo, Queen Bee by Sarah Freeman, Peanut Butter Blast by Christine Sutter, Chagrin S’Mores by Ella Laneve, Chocolate Rice Krispie Treat by Sydney Corcoran, and Take Me Out To The Ballgame by Mia Conte.

Welcome to Dairy Island. We appreciate your business. Thank you.